Patrick Starrr‘s review of Selena Gomez’s newly-launched Rare Beauty caused quite a bit of buzz this week on social media, and now Gomez’s brand has officially responded.
ICYMI, Starrr posted a video on September 6 where he tried out all of the Rare products, offering his thoughts on each as he went. His video ended on a positive note, with the YouTuber shouting out the concealer, blush, and lip balm as his favorite pieces in the line. “Overall, I love the brand. It’s very clean, fresh, natural.”
However, some fans took issue with his review, accusing the YouTuber of comparing Gomez’s products to his own and using the video to advertise his own brand, ONE/SIZE Beauty. “I feel like if you don’t actually want to promote brands other than your own, then just don’t do reviews,” one fan commented on the video, with another writing: “He literally compares his brand to hers the whole time.”
While fans certainly had a lot to say about Starrr’s video, Rare Beauty proved to be pretty unbothered by the entire situation. On September 10, the brand tweeted that they were “so thrilled” by all of the positive feedback about the line so far, adding that it’s been “uplifting to see how much love and support we’re receiving from the community for our brand mission and our products.”
Rare went on to note that everyone has different opinions and preferences when it comes to makeup, and that not every product is going to work the same way for everyone. “That’s okay!” the official account wrote in a follow-up tweet before addressing Starrr’s video directly: “@patrickstarrr is such a positive voice in this community and an incredible creator and entrepreneur so let’s all show him nothing but love!”
The fan reaction to Rare’s tweets was pretty mixed; some folks seemed satisfied with the beauty brand’s statement, while others doubled down on their initial opinions regarding the video. But it seems as though all’s well that ends well between Gomez and Starrr; the YouTuber later posted a comment of his own in response to Rare’s tweets, writing: “Alexa play ‘Kill Em with Kindness.’ Love u @selenagomez, congrats on the launch.” Beauty drama, squashed.
This story originally appeared on teenvogue.com.
Read more about Rare Beauty:
Now, learn how to recreate Selena Gomez’s beauty looks: